FELLOWSHIP for INTERNATIONAL SERVICE and HEALTH
Colaborando con nuestras comunidades locales y globales para proveer servicios de salud y educacionales sustentables
Volunteerism vs. Voluntourism
What are volunteerism and voluntourism, and what is the difference between the two? This is an essential question that FISH keeps in mind with our work in Maclovio Rojas, Mexico, to ensure that our services prioritize and benefit the community. Here, a brief comparison of voluntourism and volunteerism is provided. Additional resources with further information on the topic are provided below.
Voluntourism
Although the exact definition of voluntourism varies by situation, it is broadly thought of as the combination of a vacation and an act of service. The volunteering that is performed in voluntourism is often short-term, through non-community-based organizations, and prioritizes what outsiders may see as support rather than what the community actually wants or needs. While the intentions of people engaging in voluntourism are not always wrong, the effects are non-specific, unsustainable, and sometimes damaging to the community, only benefiting the volunteer and the organization they volunteer with.
Volunteerism
Rather than a stand-alone experience viewed as part of an overall vacation, volunteerism prioritizes sustainable and community-based work. Through volunteerism, volunteers work in communication with local leaders on long-term and internally supported community-led programs. This empowers the community and ensures sustainable structures of support rather than forcing a temporary and nonspecific solution that creates a reliance on outside interest and resources. Also, volunteers engaging in volunteerism form meaningful and long-term connections with people of the community, engaging with local culture and practices.
NEWS/LAY ARTICLES:
The business of voluntourism: do western do-gooders actually do harm?
This article by The Guardian examines the role that the voluntourism industry plays in sustaining unethical orphanages in Guatemala, as well as its appeal to people from wealthy countries despite its harmful consequences.
Why you shouldn’t participate in voluntourism
This article discusses how in most cases, voluntourism does not help, and many times even harms, the community it is supposedly attempting to help. The article also explains the importance of involving the community itself with project decisions, and making sure that organizations have a long-term plan of ethically improving the community.
Johns Hopkins interactive case studies
These interactive case studies by the Johns Hopkins Institute of Bioethics consist of three different scenarios which involve certain ethical issues about cultural competency.
ACADEMIC ARTICLES:
“English for the global”: discourses in/of English-language voluntourism
This academic paper explores the practice of English-language voluntourism, or the use of the English language in voluntourism abroad, and its problematic nature.
‘Looks good on your CV’: The sociology of voluntourism recruitment in higher education
This sociological academic paper investigates the harmful implications of using career development as an incentive for college students to participate in voluntourism.